Friday, April 15, 2011

Musings: Song - Affirmation

This is one of my favorite songs.

If only more people around the world believe as I do, as clearly written in this song, then there would be less prejudice and discrimination...

I believe the sun should never set upon an argument
I believe we place our happiness in other people's hands
I believe that junk food tastes so good because it's bad for you
I believe your parents did the best job they knew how to do
I believe that beauty magazines promote low self esteem
I believe I'm loved when I'm completely by myself alone

I believe in Karma what you give is what you get returned
I believe you can't appreciate real love 'til you've been burned
I believe the grass is no more greener on the other side
I believe you don't know what you've got until you say goodbye

I believe you can't control or choose your sexuality
I believe that trust is more important than monogamy
I believe your most attractive features are your heart and soul
I believe that family is worth more than money or gold
I believe the struggle for financial freedom is unfair
I believe the only ones who disagree are millionaires

I believe in Karma what you give is what you get returned
I believe you can't appreciate real love 'til you've been burned
I believe the grass is no more greener on the other side
I believe you don't know what you've got until you say goodbye

I believe forgiveness is the key to your unhappiness
I believe that wedded bliss negates the need to be undressed
I believe that God does not endorse tv evangelists
I believe in love surviving death into eternity

I believe in Karma what you give is what you get returned
I believe you can't appreciate real love 'til you've been burned
I believe the grass is no more greener on the other side
I believe you don't know what you've got until you say goodbye(Repeat 2)
Until you say goodbye
Oh no no no no no ( Repeats itself many times fading)

Artist: Savage Garden

Thursday, April 14, 2011

Travel Photo of the Day: Bangladesh train during Eid holidays



And I thought this happens only in the movies or in the yellowed pages of Discovery magazine or National Geographic journal.

This is a normal scene during Eid holidays in Bangladesh. I took this photo while inside the train myself. The carriages were already cramped, with literally no leg room for you to stretch your legs. You need to go to the toilet? Forget it. You wouldn't get there unless you trample on the countless bodies of women, children, and the elderly that have claimed the train floor as their seat, or in some cases, bed. Besides, the toilet would be far from clean in this crowd, to say the least.

During this particular time when I took the photo, our train was stopped for more than two hours a few kilometers from a bridge. Apparently, there was an accident in the train behind us: one man was decapitated by a bridge. He was standing on the roof of the train probably looking at the other end with his back to the front of the train, not aware that the train was about to pass under a bridge, or maybe he miscalculated his height and that of the bridge. However it happened, the important thing is it did happen.

He was one of the passengers who had the misfortune of not having a ticket, still desperate to get to his family and made the fatal decision to go ahead and stay on top of the train despite laws banning it. Yes, riding on the roof of the train is actually prohibited in Bangladesh. But I did not see any police or railway official trying to implement it this time. Either they did not have the heart to deprive the people the opportunity to see their families, or that they did not have the courage to face what would surely become violent commuters if anybody tried. Or maybe both. They have done this for so many years anyway. But as the story of the decapitated man shows, laws are there for a reason. In this case, it is actually to protect the citizens, and not to prevent them from going home.

Wednesday, April 13, 2011

Travel Photo of the Day: Tibetans Praying in front of Potala Palace in Lhasa



This is an early morning scene just outside the gates of the Potala Palace in Lhasa.

The best thing about Tibet is that you feel like you have left your mundane issues of daily living with the world below. Every single day of my two-week stay in Tibet I walked around without any specific destination in mind, letting my feet take me; greeting strangers with a smile as local practice dictated, observed people as was my training, and simply soaked in the good clean air without a care in the world on where I would get my next meal, or if my boss has emailed me.

It was on one of these days that I found myself walking just in front of Potala Palace at around 6:00 in the morning. That's right, a cold 6 AM. But instead of empty streets that usually characterize any urban setting at this unGodly hour, albeit a very high one but urban nonetheless, I was amazed to see that there were already quite a number of Tibetans up and about. Not only that. What was more remarkable was that not all of them came to the palace to pray. Rather, most of them were only pedestrians on their way to work or to some other destination, and yet, they never failed to stop and do their praying motions. This is what I'd call devotion.

So, what are the Tibetan praying motions? You put your palms together in a typical praying position, then you raise it above your head, just touching the base of your palms on the top of your head. With the palms still together, you then bring your hands to your face, touching your thumbs to your forehead. Then, with the palms still together, you bring your hands to your chest, touching the thumbs again in the middle just below your collarbones. Finally, you get down on your knees and slowly prostrate yourself on your belly, with your hands palm down and your forehead touching the ground.

I have actually tried this myself, twice or thrice, when one of the devotees in front of the Jokhang Temple kindly explained and showed it to me. I felt awkward and I guess their constant practice must have made them look more graceful and fluid. He also lent me his mat. Most of the Tibetans who do this for one whole day or days always have mats and some soft cushions for their hands. The cold hard ground can be painful on your palms, knees and chest if you do this tens of times in a day.

I've also asked the Tibetan devotee what the three positions of the hands meant, and he told me that it symbolizes the Buddha of the past (top of the head), Buddha of the present (forehead), and Buddha of the future (chest); the last one symbolizing hope. They actually have names for these three Buddhas, but I can't remember it now. I also can't get any information on the internet to corroborate this explanation. So, I will just have to take my source's word for it.

The Tibetans whisper a prayer while doing these motions, but I didn't get to learn that. If you're into Buddhism, especially Tibetan Buddhism, maybe you can start with the generic prayer of "Om Mane Padme Ohm" which is recited over and over while turning the prayer wheel. I don't know if the prayer for this praying motions are different. Maybe somebody more knowledgeable can tell me that...

Tuesday, April 12, 2011

Cairo: Of Pyramids and Sphinx



If you plan on going to the Giza Pyramids in Egypt, you better allot one whole day. It’s not because of the distance from Cairo. On the contrary, it is very near Cairo. It is because you’d need time to walk around, stare at the pyramids, line up to go inside, observe people around the compound, and just soak in the pyramid landscape. You have an option to go on a camel around the pyramids if you have trouble walking. But it is very expensive and tones down your experience of trudging in the desert and getting sand all over your sandals or shoes. Also, the tickets to enter the Great Pyramids are sold only at 1:00 PM (I think they sell all morning tickets to the group tours).

For this reason, I went to the Giza Pyramids twice. My first visit to the Giza Pyramids and the Sphinx was hurried. They say that the easiest way to go to Memphis, Dhashur and Saqqara is either by joining a tour or hiring a cab yourself. I opted for the latter. I hired a cab to go to the Giza Pyramids first, and then on to the three sites. I believed it when they said that half day with the Giza Pyramids would be enough. They’re wrong, especially when you are into these ancient architecture and civilization like I am. As I learned from this experience, it is a bad idea to lump the three sites with the Giza Pyramids.

Aside from the fact that the compound of the pyramids is quite vast to cover by foot (I decided to just walk around instead of hire a camel), I also wanted to stare at the wonders, observe the people and take a lot of photos. So obviously, I had no time during that first visit to wait for the tickets as I had to rush to Dhashur, Saqqara and Memphis. All sites in Cairo close at 4:30 and these three sites were much farther than expected.

I left the Giza pyramids at around 1:00 pm, getting a shwarma and soda along the way to Dhashur. It was quite far from Cairo and I had less than two hours left for the three sites. I just took pictures of the Bent Pyramid and the Red Pyramid in Dhashur before dashing back to the cab to go to Saqqara. My cab driver talked to another driver who suggested that we go to Saqqara first before Memphis since Memphis only has a museum. By the end of the day I was so tired and dissatisfied. I wasn’t able to enjoy and examine the sites to my little heart’s content.

Thus, it was only on my second visit that I spent some time staring up at the Great Pyramid and wondering how the ancient Egyptians could have done such feats. The pyramids must be the most photographed structure on Earth. Children from all over the world grew up in this era learning about the pyramids and how it is the only surviving ancient wonder. It is in world history books, scientific journals, travel magazines, and the National Geographic and Discovery channels.

When you look at pictures, you’d see the pyramids towering over tiny people in the background and you’d wonder just how huge it must be. And yet, when I saw these giant wonders, I was disappointed. It didn’t quite measure up to my expectations in terms of size; it didn’t seem as big as shown in the photos. It, however, measured up to being a wonder.

Each block of stone that made up the whole structure must weigh a ton. Without the machines that we employ nowadays, it’s a miracle that the ancient Egyptians were able to put one on top of another in a very engineering-accurate way. I walked around it, looked up at the top when my lower back and neck would allow, observe the people, took photos with different lighting from the sun and from different angles, and basically just marveled at the pile of stone that majestically rose up to the sky.

I also stayed with the Sphinx for quite some time. But unlike the pyramid which you can actually examine closely from all sides, only one side of the Sphinx was open to the public. It was undergoing major maintenance to arrest its slow decay; the Sphinx is already being eaten away from the inside, with the water from the Nile River slowly eroding the foundations. I observed that they have tried to reinforce the base. This is obvious at the rear end of the Sphinx, which is seldom seen by the public. I don’t know if the Sphinx ever had a tail, but it was definitely missing. Also, like most statues in Egypt, the Sphinx is missing its nose. If you follow the Egyptian belief that the dead would need everything for the afterlife, then the dead would definitely need his/her nose. So, I wondered why robbers and tomb raiders break the noses.

I also went further to the other excavation sites across the pathway from the Sphinx, just beyond the Great Pyramid where camel drivers take their clients to see the city beyond. There was nothing much to see but more rubble and sand. However, it gave me the creeps. There were underground openings (could be man-made or a cave) that were fitted with wooden doors and padlocked. The whole area was practically shouting “ancient” and I wondered what the tomb robbers could have taken from there, or what other undiscovered relic could still be lying underneath all the stones and sand.

How to go to Giza Pyramids: You can take the metro to Giza (only one Egyptian Pound) and then take a cab from the Giza metro station to the pyramids (should not be more than 15 LE). This is the cheapest and easiest way.

Monday, April 11, 2011

Travel Photo of the Day: Tibetan Horseman



I dare you to try this!

Our travel group, going on an overland tour from Kathmandu, Nepal to Lhasa, Tibet saw this Tibetan horseman. He was one of a dozen or so horsemen who were doing their tricks out in the open field beside the highway. They were probably practising for a horse riding competition. Our driver and tour guide was kind enough to allow us a few minutes to watch the spectacle from the roadside.

This was how it goes as I observed it: the horseman starts out on top of his horse racing towards the other side of the track in regular upright position. He then twists his body around in the middle of the track to try to touch the ground with his hands without stopping the horse. He comes back upright on his horse again just before he reaches the end.

I don't know the objective behind this trick or its history. I know much less if there is actually a regular competition for this trick or hwo this is judged. But, there were about a dozen horsemen doing this trick one at a time. And while it was obviosuly not a full blown horse race or horse fetival, there were several spectators on one side who were cheering them on, probably people from their own community come to see the tricks or even judge who goes to comnpete.

Too bad we had to be on our way we didn't have the time to talk to any one of the horsemen or the cheering crowd. Some children came to us though, out of curiousity as most children in all parts of the world do. Maybe next time I go to Tibet, I will have the time to stop and talk to these people and learn about their culture...

Saturday, April 9, 2011

Travel Photo of the Day: Turquoise Lake, Tibet




A lake on top of the world!

This is the Turquoise Lake in Tibet that takes more than two hours to circumnavigate by road. This can be seen along the highway from Nepal to Lhasa. It freezes during winter.

Friday, April 8, 2011

Travel Photo of the Day: Tibet Landscape



















One of my favorite spots on planet Earth!


This is located along the highway from Nepal to Lhasa. The river in the valley leads to Turquiose Lake, a huge lake in the highest place on earth. Being in this spot makes me realize just how small and inconsequential I am, and all humans are, in the greater scheme of things.

Musings: Poem - The Invitation

Here's a very good poem that was shared by a colleague during one of our conferences and I love it so much I like to share it with you all. I don't know the source and the publisher. I hope the author will pardon me for quoting the whole poem here.

THE INVITATION

"It doesn’t interest me what you do for a living.
I want to know what you ache for,
and if you dare to dream of meeting your heart’s longing.

It doesn’t interest me how old you are.
I want to know if you will risk looking like a fool for love,
for your dreams, for the adventure of being alive.

It doesn’t interest me what planets are squaring your moon.
I want to know if you have touched the centre of your own sorrow,
if you have been opened by life’s betrayals
or have become shrivelled and closed from fear of further pain.

I want to know if you can sit with pain, mine or your own,
without moving to hide it or fix it.

I want to know if you can be with joy, mine or your own,
if you can dance with wildness and
let ecstasy fill you to the tips of your fingers and toes
without cautioning us to be careful, be realistic,
or to remember the limitations of being human.

It doesn’t interest me if the story you’re telling me is true.
I want to know if you can disappoint another to be true to yourself;
If you can bear the accusation of betrayal and not betray your own soul.

I want to know if you can be faithful and therefore be trustworthy.

I want to know if you can live with failure, yours and mine,
and still stand on the edge of a lake and shout to the silver of the full moon “YES!”

It doesn’t interest me to know who you are, how you came to be here.
I want to know if you will stand in the centre of the fire with me and not shrink back.

It doesn’t interest me where or what or with whom you have studied.
I want to know what sustains you from the inside when all else falls away.

I want to know if you can be alone with yourself,
and if you truly like the company you keep in the empty moments."


By:
Oriah Mountain Dreamer
a Native American Elder

Tuesday, April 5, 2011

From Hanoi, Vietnam to Vientiane, Laos: Worst Border Crossing Ever!

It was the last leg of our four-country marathon holiday. Though the adrenaline was still pumping through our veins, we were looking forward to the rest that the long overland crossing between Vietnam and Laos will afford us. We’ve gone through Thailand, Cambodia and Vietnam. The last country on our list was Laos before going back to Bangkok through Chiang Mai.

The trip started out well. The bus picked us up from our hotel as agreed. When all the 14 passengers were on board, they gave us hot towels and bottled water. It looked like a proper tourist bus with extra unoccupied seats. In less than three hours, we started dozing off. We were awakened around midnight by the driver who told us to get off and wait for another bus coming from Hanoi which will bring us to the border. Grumbling and complaining that this was not what we paid for, we had no choice but to get off. Otherwise, the bus will take us back to Hanoi and you don’t want to be caught overstaying Vietnam.

We found ourselves somewhere in Dong Ha where we were supposed to cross to Vientiane, in a small roadside restaurant facing a small hill with no other house or any building in sight. There was only the highway to Hanoi in the north and to Ho Chi Minh in the south.

Refusing to be anxious and assured that the second bus will pick us up in an hour or so, we ordered dinner and sat around the tables chatting. But hours dragged on and no bus ever stopped to pick us up. We had no choice but to spend the night in the poorly-lit restaurant with unfriendly staff. When we started spreading out our mats and sleeping bag in the only space in front of the restaurant, conflict ensued. The restaurant owners/staff not want the stranded passengers to sleep in front of the restaurant. But there was no other place to camp, unless you want to camp out in the highway or in the dark bushes beside the restaurant.

To make matters worse, one of the passengers, a young girl of 17 from Sweden who was travelling with her friend, was bitten by a snake during the night. We had to beg for 45 minutes with the restaurant owner to bring her to the hospital before they finally conceded with a charge of 100USD. After two hours, she came back with a bandage and told us that the snake was poisonous and that she could have died from the bite if we waited longer.

The incident with the snake only heightened our anxiety and did not help in our relationship with the restaurant staff. They did not become friendlier, nor did they relax from harassing us to move out of the way. Well, to be honest, they became hostile several times during the night, and more so during the day when other people came in to eat. On our part, we were pretty sure they were conniving with the tour operators to get customers in their middle-of-nowhere restaurant. So we weren’t also very cooperative.

After lunch the following day, a bus finally stopped to pick us up. But there was a catch: it wasn’t the bus from Hanoi with more tourists going for the border crossing. It was a regular public bus that plies the route, but we didn’t care. We just wanted to leave the place and get on with our trip. The bus stopped several times along the road to take on more passengers or to let people off but we were just too happy to be moving. At one point when the bus was full, some passengers clambered on the roof of the bus through the windows, alarming many of the western passengers, but only amusing the Asians. And just like the stories about transportation in developing countries in Asia and Africa, the bus also took on livestock and furniture along with the people. This provided some entertainment for us until that last stop.

The bus stopped for the last time for a family who appeared to be moving their whole household and everything the house contained, from beds, tables, chairs to house plants and pets. Thirty minutes on the road with this house-full load, we heard a bang that sounded like a gunshot. Then the bus suddenly swerved from side to side before skidding to a halt. Obviously, the bang was the sound of tire bursting. The passengers screamed and shouted. Good thing we were between farms and not the cliffside. When the bus finally screeched to a halt, the drivers spent thirty minutes arguing what to do before they decided that we will proceed on a snail’s pace with the busted tire.

When we arrived in the nearest town at past six in the evening, the bus drivers let us off to wait for another bus but refused to give us back part of our money to finish our trip to Vientiane. By this time, you can only imagine the frustration and anger that we felt. It was then that we learned that we actually paid different rates, from 14 to 19 dollars per person.

We finally arrived in Vientiane at midnight. What was supposed to be a nine-hour (at the most) border crossing took 30 hours! It was the worst bus ride, the worst border crossing and the worst form of hospitality from any country I’ve ever experienced. So, to those who are planning to do the land border crossing from Vietnam to Laos, let me tell you it’s not worth the money that you’ll save or the time that you’d otherwise spend in more productive holiday activities.

Wednesday, December 15, 2010

CSOs, HIV&AIDS and Human Rights in Ethiopia

There are two major actors in the struggle against the issues of human rights and HIV&AIDS in Ethiopia – the government and the civil society organizations (CSOs).

The international community has recognized and agreed that HIV&AIDS is both a human rights and development issue. Given the rising trend of human rights violations in relation to HIV&AIDS, both governments and CSOs are under pressure to address HIV&AIDS using the rights-based approach. This pressure is stronger in Sub-Saharan Africa where HIV&AIDS is more prevalent, and human rights violations in relation to HIV&AIDS are widespread.

In response to these pressures, the South African Development Community (SADC) drafted a model law on HIV&AIDS in 2008. This model law is based on the right-based approach to HIV&AIDS and has raised the hopes of many human rights activists. While Ethiopia is not a member of the SADC, it may have to draft its own law to address the human rights issues in relation to HIV&AIDS. Ethiopia is signatory to the several international human rights policies which bind the Ethiopian government to conform with international human rights principles.

However, the Ethiopian government has drafted a law in 2008 deemed by many development actors in the international community as contrary to the human rights principles. The Charities and Societies Proclamation law (CSO law) restricts the activities of CSOs in the general issue of human rights. Under this law, foreign CSOs are prohibited from engaging in human rights activities. The definition of foreign CSOs includes not only the actual international foreign NGOs, but also those local NGOs/CSOs that get more than 10% of its income from external sources. This translates to most local NGOs being prohibited to engage in human rights activities.

The CSO law has alarmed international development actors. Some human rights activists claim that the law is an attempt to conceal human rights violations. There were advocacies from international and local CSOs, as well as from developed nations, for the Ethiopian government to change some stipulations in the law, especially with regards to human rights. Some human rights activists called on international donors and funding nations to sanction the Ethiopian government for this blatant disregard of human rights principles.

Sunday, July 26, 2009

Connected to the Big World once again...

Last June 14 until July 22, 2009 my wireless internet modem decided to take an unofficial vacation by itself. I was so surprised when I tried to connect and the screen read "Error in connection.Cannot find the source and server."

What happened? I had just recharged my monthly rate of Rs498 and no connection????!!!! Got to visit the customer care office again, I groaned. But then when???? With my calendar full of field visits, I hardly got time and importantly the energy to deal with the horrendous traffic, deafening noise pollution and the crazy speed of the bus drivers. Scanning my calendar again, trying to see where I can fit a visit to the network office....Sigh...none...No choice but to go Sunday....

Sunday came and off I went to the office but surprise surprise....the systems are not working on Sundays....Oh bugger.....Now what????!!! I am hyperventilating with the thought of no connection for quite a long time......Is this withdrawal symptoms???? Am I addicted to the net now??? I guess it unknowingly develops when you are homesick and alone in the place surrounded by people who speak a different langauge and who thinks you have strange food habits and lifestyle...

But God is so good. He knows I am slowly going crazy and is on my way to a major depression if this goes on a little longer...He gave me Wednesday to be free ( no field visit,yehey) and gave me the strength and the patience to endure the 2 hours long crazy bus ride to Golpark. I had my modem checked and in less than 5 minutes its good again!!!! I can't wait to try it once I am home!

So I am again blogging and chatting and emailing and networking and surfing....ahhhhhh...the addict in me is now truly very happy and satisfied.....It's so good to be connected to the wide world again:)

Oooppsss...its past bed time...Got to sleep now...Will be buying fish early tomorrow for this week source of protein....Wishing for beef but....wishful thinking....

Next week, Orccha here we come!!! So excited to see the Kamasutra in stone at Khajuraho...time to brush up my lessons on sexuality and sensuality....wink wink...

As for now, good night India and good night world...I'm off to dreamland.....zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz..........

Wednesday, June 10, 2009

Notes: Children in Sex Work - Part 3

In all my travels and years in development work, I always find the plight of children to be disturbing. As a foreigner and tourist in developing countries, I can’t help but notice children in the streets begging or being involved in the flesh trade. It is the latter that I find most upsetting. I know that the main reason behind these activities is poverty. But I can’t also help but wonder if children engaged in sex work are pure victims, or do they exercise human agency in making sense of, and living in the social world of sex work? What aspects of sex work are open to their decision-making? And how do children decide and interpret their engagement in this occupation?

This is the last part of my 3-part post.

THE RIGHT TO SELF-DETERMINATION
In all free societies, the right to self-determination is a fundamental right. As such, all people, adult and children alike, possess it. However, children being young and immature, are considered to be lacking in adult reasoning and knowledge, and are thus incapable of being responsible for their deeds or for making the rational decision for themselves. Adults, then, through the state, and primarily, the family, uphold the right of self-determination for the children and deny them the right to make a choice.

Thus, while children possess this fundamental right, they are unable to exercise it. Yet, the child is not a mere innocent and passive social actor. The children sex workers are not mere victims who do nothing about their circumstances. They may have limitations, but they are also active agents that actively participate in the production and reproduction of the social rules and structures in sex work, even if only at their level.

The mere recognition by the child that she is an agent, and by claiming her body as her own resource, the child has effectively shown that she is a knowledgeable and competent social agent, albeit a limited one. Whenever they disobey their managers, they always refer to their own body as theirs, and so the decision on what to do with it should only be theirs.

The children sex workers have also shown that they are capable of rational decisions based on the choices available to them. All of them underwent a rational decision-making process in choosing to remain in sex work and refusing assistance from government and other institutions. As stated earlier, both Two of the children find sex work as a better alternative to their past lives. One rationalized that sex work is better than begging or vending in the streets as it gives her security of shelter, food and stable income. The other prefers sex work over being raped by her uncle and step cousin. For her, sex work is purely an economic transaction between her and the customers where she can exercise her agency, while rape is actually a situation of abuse where her agency is repressed.

Findings of studies also demonstrate that the children sex workers are in fact very effective agents to the point of defeating the social welfare institutions with their refusal to cooperate. Most of the institutions that have attempted to help them have always asked them about their families. These institutions believe that the families should be informed of the children's plight. But this is exactly the opposite of what the children want.

Two children refused outside attempts to help them get out of sex work for fear that their families will be involved. Both know that sex work is considered to be deviant and unacceptable, and they are afraid that they will be ostracized by their own family and friends for being involved in sex work. Mary, for her part, did not want her family to know about her plight because of her uncle's threat of killing her parents and siblings if she reported the rape/abuse to the authorities.

I conclude that child sex workers are not mere victims of exploitation. They are victims of society’s perception of them. They are victims of the very theories and policies that seek to protect them. Yet, they are also active social actors in sex work who both break and follow rules that consequently keep them in sex work. Regardless of their lack of knowledge and skills, and despite their lack of resources, children sex workers are competent agents in sex work, who, like all adults in society, do not want other people to deprive them of their right to exercise their agency and self-determination.

The right to self-determination is a fundamental right that is central to the issue of children’s liberation. It is essential to all the rights of the child. Thus, society should acknowledge this right. However, the acknowledgment and acceptance of the right of the child to self-determination by society should also be balanced by the recognition of the limitations of the child’s agency. Therefore, it is imperative that policies and programs for possible interventions affecting children sex workers must take into consideration both the agency and structured constraints of the child.

This post (including parts 1 & 2) is based on the paper "Children in Sex Work: Is There Room for Social Agency" that I presented during the Fifth National Social Science Congress at the Philippine Social Science Council in May 2003. The views reflected on all parts of this 3-part post are mine alone and does not in any way assume to have the same ideals and statements of the Philippine Social Science Council . If you have any comments, please feel free to do so...

Friday, June 5, 2009

Notes: Children in Sex Work - Part 2

In all my travels and years in development work, I always find the plight of children to be disturbing. As a foreigner and tourist in developing countries, I can’t help but notice children in the streets begging or being involved in the flesh trade. It is the latter that I find most upsetting. I know that the main reason behind these activities is poverty. But I can’t also help but wonder if children engaged in sex work are pure victims, or do they exercise human agency in making sense of, and living in the social world of sex work? What aspects of sex work are open to their decision-making? And how do children decide and interpret their engagement in this occupation?

This is the second of this 3-part post.

THE CHILD AS A SOCIAL AGENT
People acquire the capacities necessary to be agents in the social world, at the same time that society both enables and constrains the exercise of this agency. By active participant, I presuppose the intentionality and willingness of the child’s agency regardless of, and given, its limited experience and bounded knowledge – connoting the concept of the child sex worker’s limited agency and bounded realities.

Thus, I contend that children sex workers have both the practical and discursive knowledge, however limited these may be, of the rules and structures in the social world. These include authority structures and role-specific social structures that guide the actions, interactions, and relations of social actors in the process of exercising their agency through restructuration (reproduction of social structures) and destructuration (breaking the rules and preventing the reproduction of structures).

This contention presupposes the rationality of the children sex workers as it is imperative to establish the intentionality of the child as active social agents, albeit a limited one given the limitations of the child’s knowledge and experience. While knowledgeability is founded less upon discursive consciousness than practical consciousness; human agents always know what they are doing on the level of discursive under some description.

I further contend that the child’s agency is limited compared to the adult; the child’s exercise of agency is bounded by the lack of knowledge and experience by virtue of their age, and not because of their incapacity for reason. The adult is more “rational” than the child in the sense that the adult has more time than the child to acquire knowledge and experience, and to exercise the ability to reason. In other words, the child is capable of reason as far as her knowledge and experience allows.

Thus, I also contend that the limited knowledge and experience of the children sex workers does not prevent them from exercising their agency in their everyday life situations, however limited her agency may be compared to the adult social actors in sex work.

The children sex workers I have interviewed and observed were 14 years old. Prior to sex work, the social worlds of these three children were limited only to the family and, in one case, to the gang, as well. The very limited knowledge and experience of the children sex workers, which form their discursive and practical consciousness, were founded on this bounded reality as they entered sex work.

Furthermore, the social rules and structures in sex work affect the agency of the child. Most of the social rules and structures in sex work are mainly based on the social constructions of childhood and sexuality characterized by adult and male bias. Thus, as the child exercises her agency in sex work in her everyday interactions and relations with the pimps, managers, and customers, the child finds her agency to be limited not only by her bounded reality, but also by the social rules and structures in sex work.

Wait for the last part of this 3-part post...

Tuesday, June 2, 2009

Notes: Children in Sex Work - Part 1

In all my travels and years in development work, I always find the plight of children to be disturbing. As a foreigner and tourist in developing countries, I can’t help but notice children in the streets begging or being involved in the flesh trade. It is the latter that I find most upsetting. I know that the main reason behind these activities is poverty. But I can’t also help but wonder if children engaged in sex work are pure victims, or do they exercise human agency in making sense of, and living in the social world of sex work? What aspects of sex work are open to their decision-making? And how do children decide and interpret their engagement in this occupation?

ADULTHOOD AND RATIONALITY
Many studies have been conducted on the involvement of children in sex work, but very few studies have dealt with the issue from the perspective of the child, as it is being lived and experienced by the child herself. Policies and laws regarding children reflect the social construction of children as incompetent human beings who lack reason and are thus “incapable of supporting themselves and of acting for their best interest.” Because of their perceived inability to act rationally, children are not allowed to participate in the adult world, and are seen to require the protection and supervision of adults. It is this adult bias that leads society to approach the issue of children’s sex work from an adult perspective.

However, there is no defining line that distinguishes the rational adult from the rational child. While adulthood is associated with full rationality, childhood cannot be considered as a period of complete lack of reason, since maturity and development of reason is a gradual process through the acquisition of ideas and experiences. As such, I contend that regardless of the limitation of knowledge and experiences of the child, the child makes sense of the social world in the process of living in it. I support the contention that human beings both act in the social world, and are acted upon by it.

In general, adults are assumed to be the only knowledgeable, active and competent social actors in society. Children are considered incapable of making the right decisions and taking the right actions because they are not yet equipped with the skill to make rational decisions, and they lack the knowledge of the rules and structures of society that would enable them to become active and competent actors. Thus, as a rule, adults make decisions for children until such time that the latter are deemed competent and fully capable of deciding and acting for their best interests.

In most countries, the transition from childhood to adulthood is defined by age; a person is considered to be an adult upon reaching the age of 18 years. Only then can the person act and be treated as an adult. Individuals have to undergo a process of socialization throughout their childhood and adolescence in order to prepare them to become adults. It is through the socialization process that social actors learn the social rules and structures of society that would guide their behavior and actions in any situation.

Through socialization, children are taught the idea of self-determination, and of agency, during this preparatory phase. They learn to exercise their agency. Society has even formed social structures that would facilitate a more ordered socialization of children. First and foremost of these are the family and school.

However, in the case of the children sex workers who are living apart from their family, and are not in school, their socialization has to be continued in their everyday life, and with the social actors in sex work. Sex work can then be considered as both the context and the process by which the children sex workers are socialized into a world of social inequality, based on social class, gender and age.

Wait for the 2nd part of this 3-part post...

Wednesday, May 27, 2009

Holy Water: Cure-All in Ethiopia

There is one hotel in Addis Ababa that volunteers from other parts of Ethiopia often use when they come to the capital. The manager in this hotel is very friendly towards all patrons, especially volunteers. It was during one of my medical check-ups that I had this funny and illuminating conversation with him.

“You look tired. Where have you been?” He asked politely.
“Oh, I went to the hospital.” I answered.
“You’re sick?”
“Yeah, I am.”
“You know, I have a cure for that. I can give it to you for free.” He enthusiastically informed me.
“Oh yeah, what is it?”
“Holy water.”
“I’m sorry?” I asked again, unsure that I heard him right.
“Holy water."

At this point I can’t help but laugh. I knew that he meant well and I did apologize for laughing.

"It can cure you of your sickness. It can cure anybody of any disease.” He insisted.
“But I don’t believe in holy water.”
“It’s true. I assure you.” He replied, with his right hand raised in the manner of taking a serious oath.
“Well, then you should probably boil it first before I can take it. We’ve been warned against drinking water that has not been boiled and filtered.”
“But that would take away its healing powers.” He answered, eyebrows raised slightly and eyes rounding in surprise.

I laughed again. My well-intentioned hotel manager was disappointed and aghast at the mere suggestion of boiling the holy water. But he and his staff laughed with me. They probably realized the futility of convincing me of their holy water’s powers.

Pardon my ignorance, but apparently, this holy water comes from a holy spring. The sanctity of the source is what makes the water holy. Thus, boiling it is out of the question.

Well, should I risk drinking the pure holy water for a possibility of being cured? Not a chance. But that conversation left me with a feeling of hope; that there are still some people who believe in miracles even if I don’t believe them myself.

Saturday, May 23, 2009

Notes: Poverty and Development – Part 4

As a development worker working and traveling in developing countries, I noticed one common and disturbing theme: POVERTY. For me, poverty is THE development issue. It has been a perennial problem that majority of the world’s population faces. But the lack of impact of development efforts on developing countries, despite the years and the billions of dollars spent on programs makes me wonder if development programs helping poor countries as intended or are they fostering dependency on international aid, corruption within the government and consequently, furthering poverty and underdevelopment? This has led me to one major question: what have we not done right?

This is the last part of my effort at examining the historical development trends and progress, with a focus on the Philippines.

WHAT HAVE WE NOT DONE RIGHT?
It is needless to say that capitalism prioritizes profit over everything else. Thus, it is only natural that capitalist-led development further encourages materialism and colonial mentality among Filipinos. Land conversions to give way to urbanization and industrialization went unchecked at the expense of food availability and environmental sustainability.

Despite warnings against natural resources depletion and degradation, indiscriminate logging and fishing for profit continues to destroy the ecological balance of upland, lowland and coastal ecosystems, leading to floods, soil erosion, siltation and endangerment, even extinction, of biological species. In their desire to join the export band wagon deemed to be more profitable, more farmers have turned to cash crop production oriented towards markets abroad, leaving the needs of the local people unmet and the local market weak.

The grassroots cooperatives, credit and livelihood programs implemented with funds from international donors were aimed at alleviating the financial situation of families and communities. Yet, development interventions somehow forgot to include the financial institutions’ regard for small debtors in the equation.

Despite evidence that poor people can also be responsible debtors as evidenced in the high repayment rates of credit programs, banks and other institutional lenders still ignore these people’s requests for loans to either start or expand a business. Poor people are left to the mercy of loan sharks who demand excessively high interest rates on loans which eventually lead debtors to either close and sell their businesses and other properties, or plunge them deeper in debt, or both.

The drive towards increasing access to education for all children indeed resulted to high literacy rate. But as illustrated earlier, this was not complemented with an increase in employment and business opportunities. The Philippine education system is basically employment-oriented, specifically urban employment. It fails to encourage rural occupation, environmental concern, entrepreneurship and diversification of capital.

Instead, it encourages Filipinos to put all their eggs in one basket – employment. It promotes the idea that employment, especially in multinational/international corporations within the country, or any other employment outside the country is the only way to ensure an income and bring them out of poverty. The swelling number of middle class comprised mostly of OFWs and professionals are helpless in the face of unemployment despite having some savings. This lack of initiative to invest in the country is further aggravated by the government’s ineptitude to encourage investment and promote business opportunities for the middle class.

Materialism and commercialism, both prerequisites and by-products of capitalism have bred greed and undermined positive Filipino values and traditions. Wealth became the sole measure of a man’s worth regardless of its source or the means by which it was acquired. Corruption in all levels and across all branches of the government is rampant. OFWs see each other as competitors for employment, leading to widespread distrust, skepticism, cynicism and conflict among Filipinos abroad. The Filipino value of putting the family’s needs and interests first still remains. Yet, the traditional values and practices of community cooperation (bayanihan), altruism and nationalism (pagmamalasakit sa kapwa at sa bansa), and even protection of the environment (pangangalaga sa kalikasan) are slowly deteriorating.

Donor-driven capitalist-led development in the Philippines for more than half a century has only made Philippine development highly dependent on external funding and markets. It has failed to ensure the sustainability of development. It has somehow made development as the goal in itself instead of treating it as an evolutionary process that needs to be sustained.

And this is what we have not done right in all the years and efforts on development in the Philippines. What makes it more alarming is that this is still the kind of development that is being pursued in all developing and underdeveloped countries by international development movers from the capitalist nations.

This is the last part of the Notes on Poverty and Development post. I would like to clarify that these are just my views, and mine alone. You are welcome to comment on the topic and issues discussed herein...

Wednesday, May 20, 2009

Notes: Poverty and Development – Part 3

As a development worker working and traveling in developing countries, I noticed one common and disturbing theme: POVERTY. For me, poverty is THE development issue. It has been a perennial problem that majority of the world’s population faces. But the lack of impact of development efforts on developing countries, despite the years and the billions of dollars spent on programs makes me wonder if development programs helping poor countries as intended or are they fostering dependency on international aid, corruption within the government and consequently, furthering poverty and underdevelopment? This has led me to one major question: what have we not done right?

This is the third part of my effort at examining the historical development trends and progress, with a focus on the Philippines.

THE PHILIPPINE BRAIN DRAIN
The government’s inability to utilize local resources, knowledge and skills for the development of the country is starkly evident in the education-employment situation. The high literacy rate of the Philippines did not produce the long term impact on development as expected.

It is notable that government-run public schools offer free elementary and secondary education to all Filipino children, resulting to the high literacy rate. Only a fraction of high school graduates proceeds to the next level because college or university education is very expensive. Even subsidized state colleges and universities are still too expensive for poor people to afford.

But Filipinos value education so much that poor people would go to some lengths, such as selling or borrowing (as collateral) on their meager properties (land, house, livestock, others) just to send their children to college and university. Thus, there are still a considerable number of university graduates every year who need jobs that the government is unable to provide.

This surplus of skilled labor consequently led to the Philippine “brain drain” phenomenon as more and more Filipinos seek employment abroad. The low salary rates in the country pushed even those who already hold jobs to seek employment in other countries that offer higher wages, even if it meant having to work at a much lower level than their qualifications or previous positions. Coming from the biggest English-speaking nation in Asia, with relatively cheap labor, Filipinos were the preferred choice in non-English-speaking countries.

The first to go were the teachers, midwives, accountants and secretaries to work as domestic helpers initially in neighboring rich countries like Hong Kong and Singapore. The geographical coverage eventually included Saudi Arabia and other gulf countries as the type of work also expanded to include other service-related employment, such as nursing, entertainment, hotel, restaurant and construction, among others. The recent batch of overseas Filipino workers (OFWs) was mostly comprised of medical practitioners in response to the increase in the demand for health care workers in Europe and the USA.

As gender equality spread in developed nations in the west during the last quarter of the 20th century, more jobs became available to women. Nursing, which was predominantly a female occupation became the least preferred work as women in these countries chose less demanding jobs with higher pay. Registration in nursing schools dropped, consequently leading to inadequate labor supply in hospitals and other health care institutions. Thus, by the start of the 21st century when European countries and the US found themselves needing more health care service providers to cater to the baby boomers of the 60’s, they were forced to look for labor supply outside their own territories.

Having a surplus of nurses, the Philippines became one of the first, if not the biggest supplier of health care service providers to these countries. The English language skill of Filipinos, coupled with other Filipinos characteristics and values have boosted the demand for Filipino health care workers. Enrollment in nursing and health care courses in colleges and universities increased. New training institutes specifically offering short courses on health care sprung around the country. Some of these short courses are bundled with promises of immediate employment abroad after completion of the course.

The salaries of these health workers in Europe and the US are higher than employment wages and income from professional practice in the Philippines. This encourages licensed doctors and qualified professionals from other fields (education, engineering, accounting, etc.) to go back to school to study either the four-year nursing course (for those who can afford the time and tuition) or the short health care courses.

The migration of skilled workers caused more problems other than the brain drain. It has divided families, leaving children with at least only one parent (sometimes even none). Many of the husbands and wives left behind have become dependent on their spouse’s remittances. The absence of the spouse led husbands to seek other women and wives other men. The children experienced emotional issues, resulting to delinquency and other social problems. A number of husbands and wives are known to squander their spouse’s income on alcohol, gambling and luxury items. Thus, many OFWs find that they have no savings when they come home, pushing them to work abroad again. And this becomes the OFW cycle that traps them.

The brain drain phenomenon however, also had positive outcomes especially at the national and household levels. Overseas jobs have absorbed a considerable percentage of unemployed Filipinos. The remittances of OFWs comprise a sizable percentage of the GDP. It has lifted many families from poverty, allowing them to buy properties and send children to good schools.

Yet, the positive gains from the brain drain are precariously anchored on the economies of other countries. The current economic recession in Europe and the US has already affected much of the world’s economies, including Japan, one of major export markets (along with the US) of Philippine products. Being export-oriented (labor and products), the Philippines is expected to be gravely hit. The rising industry of customer service call centers in the country, which has somehow slackened the brain drain, is also expected to take a beating. These companies are mainly US and Europe-owned. As the recession continues, the companies will be forced to shrink their customer service employees in an effort to save the business from total collapse and bankruptcy.

The effects of the recession are already being felt. Many OFWs, along with call center employees find themselves unemployed. Those in cash crop production have to contend with the shrinking export market. At present, employment rate is increasing and there is a surge of OFW returnees who lost their jobs and consequently leading to a drop in remittances. All of these only prove the superficiality of Philippine development.

Please wait for the last part of this 4-part post...

Monday, May 18, 2009

Notes: Poverty and Development – Part 2

As a development worker working and traveling in developing countries, I noticed one common and disturbing theme: POVERTY. For me, poverty is THE development issue. It has been a perennial problem that majority of the world’s population faces. But the lack of impact of development efforts on developing countries, despite the years and the billions of dollars spent on programs makes me wonder if development programs helping poor countries as intended or are they fostering dependency on international aid, corruption within the government and consequently, furthering poverty and underdevelopment? This has led me to one major question: what have we not done right?

This is the second part of my effort at examining the historical development trends and progress, with a focus on the Philippines.

DEVELOPMENT IN THE PHILIPPINES
Having a history of more than half a century of development work, the Philippine experience may be the best example to illustrate my answer. Its development history has been driven by both capitalist-led interventions and socialist ideals. The oldest-known non-government organization (NGO), the Philippine Rural Reconstruction Movement (PRRM) was founded in 1952 based on Dr. Sun Yat Sen’s…

This long history of development in the Philippines has resulted to several positive outcomes. Today, the country has one of the highest literacy rates (98%) in the world. While there are still human rights violations, it boasts of having one of the highest levels of gender equality among developing nations, especially in education and employment.

Many sectoral organizations have formed national-level federations and international alliances to represent and advocate for grassroots interests. The enactment of the Local Government Code (LGC) has empowered local communities to be independent and to address problems at the local level. There has also been a noticeable decrease in the number of people living below the poverty line as the proportion of the middle class expanded.

These gains however, are currently being threatened. The World Bank has categorized the Philippines as a middle income country at the start of the 21st century (year?) due to the rise in its HDI and GDP. As a consequence, much of the international donor agencies pulled out from the country, resulting to a chain reaction starting with the closure of majority of local NGOs. Without support from the NGOs, many cooperatives and community-based organizations (CBOs) collapsed, further weakening the civil society movement.

In addition, majority of financial programs such as credit and livelihood were stopped, and environmental protection and rehabilitation activities were abandoned. In less than a decade the country’s development has regressed, leading the World Bank and other donor agencies to question if they had pulled out of the country too soon.

Blaming the country’s regression solely on the pull-out of international funding is oversimplifying the situation. There are of course several other factors that contributed to the Philippines’ regression. The Comprehensive Agrarian Reform Program (CARP) implemented in 1988 under the Aquino administration failed to protect farmers from decisions of landowners to convert agricultural lands into residential, commercial or industrial areas.

These converted lands are exempted from CARP and were not distributed to the farmers who have worked on it for decades and centuries. The land remains with the landowner. Moreover, the CARP and the government in general, failed to subsidize small farmers, leaving them vulnerable to exorbitant prices of agricultural inputs.

As the Philippine government pursued industrialization, many farmers found it more practical to sell their land for conversion than to continue tilling them. Many of those who continued farming turned to cash crops which generated more revenues than agricultural food crops. These land conversions and increase in cash crop production led to the scarcity of food in the country. It is ironic that the Philippines, host to the International Rice Research Institute (IRRI) established to increase rice production, ended up importing rice from other countries that benefitted from IRRI’s research and training.

Please wait for the 3rd part of this 4-part post...

Saturday, May 16, 2009

Notes: Poverty and Development – Part 1

As a development worker and tourist in developing countries, I noticed one common and disturbing theme: POVERTY. For me, poverty is THE development issue. It has been a perennial problem that majority of the world’s population faces. Billions of dollars have been spent on thousands of various poverty interventions. Countless seminars, fora, conferences and conventions have been held to discuss poverty and come up with workable solutions. Technological innovations have focused on increasing food production.

Despite all these efforts, poverty still remains as a huge problem in itself, as well as both a major cause and consequence of other issues that underdeveloped and developing nations struggle with. This apparent lack of impact of development initiatives on world poverty has prompted many development stakeholders to ask why, including me. It makes me wonder if development programs helping poor countries as intended or are they fostering dependency on international aid, corruption within the government and consequently, furthering poverty and underdevelopment. So, what have we not done right?

ACROSS THE YEARS
Development paradigms, approaches and interventions have evolved throughout the years. These are intricately intertwined with political-economic discourses. The first paradigm equated development with economic progress. It proposed that poverty can only be addressed through economic-oriented interventions.

With this, the socialist-communist perspective argued that only by revolutionizing the political-economy of the country can true development prosper -- by eliminating inequality, poverty will be addressed. From the other end of the political-economic spectrum, the capitalists believed that strengthening the economy is the only way to development and address poverty.

The cold war brought on not only the arms race, but also a development race. As capitalist nations tried to prevent the spread of socialism-communism to the rest of the world, development funding and interventions naturally poured in from them into the underdeveloped and developing countries. They believed that effects of economic progress will trickle down to poor countries and communities.

However, as time passed and very little change was perceived in the poverty situation of the beneficiary-nations, development planners and managers realized that economic progress, while an important prerequisite to development, is not the only aspect that needs to be addressed.

Acknowledging the cyclic nature of poverty, development initiatives moved to encompass education and health among others. This resulted to a more comprehensive measure of development. The Gross Domestic Product (GDP), considered as a reliable measure was then replaced by the Human Development Index (HDI). In line with the new encompassing approach, the HDI includes indicators on education and health, along with economic indicators like income and employment.

While equality, human rights and people’s participation are considered integral to democracy, these were yet to be realized in a capitalist-led development. Thus, as the socialist-communist nations pursued their brand of development with the same ideals of equality and empowerment, and gaining new allies along the way, development planners and managers from the rich capitalist nations had to reconsider their approaches. Equality, human rights and empowerment moved from the political sphere into the development arena.

A whole new development paradigm took shape by the last quarter of the 20th century. From the top-to-bottom approach typical of capitalism, interventions moved on to the bottom-to-top participatory approach. The focus changed from economic-centered empowerment to general political empowerment. The scope covers not only economic progress but a more holistic development that includes environmental sustainability as well. And finally, the method changed from being curative problem-oriented to preventive awareness-raising and capacity-building.

This is still the development paradigm that shapes the current development approaches and interventions. Yet, as I have noted earlier, poverty still remains, if not increasingly becoming the biggest development problem in the world. This brings us back to the question of “why.”

Please wait for Part 2 of this 4-part post...

Monday, May 11, 2009

Ethiopia: Travel Back in Time

In modern day Ethiopia, I can still see how Africa must have looked during Jesus’ era. Nothing much has changed if you compare it to paintings of olden days. It always feels like I’ve been transported in time. Only the main roads have been paved. Most streets and even major roads are still red or brown.

A big part of Ethiopia is in the Rift Valley, so they have a lot of these red volcanic rocks which they grind into smaller stones that they then spread over the streets and roads. They say it does not absorb water, instead allowing the water to go straight to the soil. So, it keeps the roads/streets from turning into mud during rainy season and peoples’ feet drier. And it actually works!

The regional capital of the Southern Nations, Nationalities and Peoples’ Regional State (SNNPRS) is Awassa. It is not that far from the capital and it is along the “best” highway in all of Ethiopia. It only takes 4 hours ride by minibus or car and 7 hours by big bus (because the big bus stops so often for food!) from the national capital, Addis Ababa. It is the second largest “city” in Ethiopia, but still looks like a small town in all aspects compared to other cities in developing countries.

For transportation, they have the autorickshaws which they call Bajaj since it is the name of the company that exports them to Ethiopia from India. It is like a motorized pedicab in Asia but much bigger wherein the passengers are behind the driver. They also have the horse-drawn carriage. Those are the main modes of transportation around the town.

For out-of-town trips, you will have to take the vans which they call the minibus or the bigger buses. You will also find donkey-drawn carts used for moving wares, water, firewood, hay, etc.

There are horses, donkeys, goats, sheep and cows everywhere. You may not know this but Ethiopia has the most number of livestock in Africa. You’ll find horses and donkey being left by their owners to fend for themselves when they are too sick to work – I mean the animals.

They don’t eat horse or donkey meat and since it would take a lot of energy to bury them when they die, dead horses and donkeys, or whatever dead livestock are left on the side of the streets as hyena meal. You’ll be amazed at how fast these hyenas can finish off a horse. A dead horse may be left in the evening and by morning you’ll only see the bones.

In Ethiopia, you’ll see the rich and the poor in the same villages which must have been the case during biblical times. They have no “rich” or “poor” villages as we know in most countries today.

The secret is that Ethiopia was a former monarchy that gives out land titles to everyone who applies for land. It is not real land ownership as we know it. Rather, it is only a transfer of land rights. And these patches of land used to be of the same size for everyone that is actually big by many developing countries’ standards.

Many compounds are separated from other houses with tall concrete walls, probably to keep off both thieves and hyenas. Others only have bamboo fences or GI sheets which I doubt would keep off neither the hyena nor the thief.

They also don’t designate areas for the poor or the rich. I think the government gives land titles depending on the area assigned to be distributed and according to whoever is applying for land by that time. When the federal government took over after the monarchy was overthrown, they did not change the system (well, I think only until recently).

So, whether you can afford to build a concrete house or only a mud hut, you’ll have the same lot size with everyone else. You own the house though, which you can sell along with the land rights.